Sleep Doctor independently selects the products we test. We may earn a commission if you buy through the links on our site.

Brooklyn Bedding Signature Mattress Review: An Affordable Hybrid

UPDATED

Written by Afy Okoye

Reviewed by Dr. Michael Breus

Expert Tested

Table of Contents

Mattress Review

Brooklyn Bedding Signature Hybrid

Details

  • Type: Hybrid

  • Firmness: Medium Soft (4), Medium Firm (6), Firm (8)

  • Sizes: Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, California King, Custom Sizes

  • Price Range: $499 – $1,199

  • Warranty: 10 Year, Limited

Highlights

  • Robust pocketed coils provide springiness and edge support
  • Choice of three firmness options
  • Hybrid design balances contouring and bounce
  • Option to add a pillow-top with cooling fibers

Drawbacks

  • May lack contouring for people who want significant hug
  • 120-night sleep trial has a return shipping fee
  • Cooling pillow-top costs extra

The Brooklyn Bedding Signature Mattress is a hybrid mattress constructed with quilted cotton, polyfoam, and pocketed coils to provide dependable support and moderate pressure relief. It is available in three different firmness levels at the same competitive price-point. The availability of multiple firmness options enables almost any sleeper to get comfortable on a Brooklyn Bedding Signature Mattress.

Sleep Doctor’s Take: Brooklyn Bedding Signature Mattress

Brooklyn Bedding is a proven brand in the mattress industry, and the Signature Mattress is a leading model, thanks to the quality materials in its multilayered hybrid design. With three firmness options to pick from and an affordable price-point, this mattress is a compelling choice for people who want all-around performance and value.

Brooklyn Bedding Signature Mattress: An Introduction

Founded in 1995, Brooklyn Bedding has been making mattresses for over 25 years. The Brooklyn Bedding Signature Mattress is one of their flagship products. This hybrid mattress, which is available in three different firmness options, combines the traditional bounce of an innerspring mattress with the comfort and support of foam comfort layers. 

We’ll cover all the key details about the Brooklyn Bedding Signature Hybrid Mattress, including how it feels to sleep on, how it performed during our in-house testing, and where the mattress can be purchased.

We also reviewed the Brooklyn Bedding Aurora Luxe, a higher end model from the same brand.

How We Review

We applied a rigorous testing methodology to evaluate the Brooklyn Bedding Signature Mattress across a range of performance categories. This analysis can help in the process of choosing the best mattress for you. In our sleep lab, our team of side, back, and stomach sleepers of different weights shared their feedback to create the most useful review for all types of sleepers.

What’s It Like to Sleep on the Brooklyn Bedding Signature Mattress?

The foam layers and cotton quilting in the Brooklyn Bedding Signature Hybrid Mattress provide good cushioning and support for a wide variety of sleepers. The thick coil layer balances out the softness by offering significant bounce and stability. 

The sleeping experience on this mattress varies depending on which firmness option you select. The softer the model, the greater the amount of contouring and cushioning, while the firmest option provides more bounce and ease of movement. On any model, an optional pillow-top adds a bit of softness along with a material engineered to cut down on heat buildup.

Brooklyn Bedding Signature Mattress Pros and Cons

Pros

  • Multiple firmness choices to suit different needs
  • Available in specialty sizes, including RV sizes
  • Provides a blend of pressure relief and bounce that can suit a wide range of sleepers

Cons

  • Thinner foam layers do not have deep contouring
  • A return shipping fee is deducted from refunds
  • Reduced motion isolation on the firm (8) model

Sleeping Positions, Body Weight, and Firmness

The Brooklyn Bedding Signature Hybrid provides three firmness options, making it appealing to many different types of sleepers. When looking for a mattress, it’s important to consider your personal preferences as well as your body weight, sleep position, and whether you experience back pain

We use a firmness scale of 1 to 10, with 1 being the softest and 10 being the firmest. On this scale, the Soft version of the Signature Hybrid is a medium soft (4), the Medium model is a medium (5), and the Firm model is a firm (8). 

Our testing team found that each model’s performance rated differently based on sleeping position and body weight.

Signature Mattress – Soft

Firmness: Medium Soft (4)

Under 130 lbs.130-230 lbs.Over 230 lbs.
Side Sleepers5/54/53/5
Back Sleepers5/53/52/5
Stomach Sleepers3/52/51/5

Signature Mattress – Medium

Firmness: Medium Firm (6)

Under 130 lbs.130-230 lbs.Over 230 lbs.
Side Sleepers3/55/53/5
Back Sleepers3/55/53/5
Stomach Sleepers4/53/52/5

Signature Mattress – Firm

Firmness: Firm (8)

Under 130 lbs.130-230 lbs.Over 230 lbs.
Side Sleepers2/53/53/5
Back Sleepers3/54/55/5
Stomach Sleepers2/55/55/5

Side Sleepers

Both the medium soft (4) and medium firm (6) versions of the Brooklyn Bedding Signature Hybrid performed well for side sleepers who need cushioning around key pressure points like the hips and shoulders. For our testers, the cushioning from the top layers provided enough pressure relief to facilitate spinal alignment. The medium soft (4) option was best for sleepers under 130 pounds, and the medium firm (6) performed best for people between 130 and 230 pounds. Side sleepers over 230 felt that all three models performed about as well as other hybrid mattresses.

Back Sleepers

Our back sleepers generally preferred the medium firm (6) and firm (8) models, which provided plenty of stable support for the lower back without permitting excess sinking into the mattress. However, back sleepers who weigh under 130 pounds preferred the medium soft (4) option. The medium firm (6) model was optimal for people between 130 and 230 pounds, and the firm (8) was the top choice for those over 230 pounds.

Stomach Sleepers

In our tests, stomach sleepers reported that they got the best support from the firm (8) model of the Signature Hybrid. Stomach sleepers need a sleep surface with less sinkage and hug so that their midsection and spine stay relatively flat. With its firmer feel and significant support, the firm (8) model provided dependable comfort, especially for sleepers over 130 pounds. For stomach sleepers under 130 pounds, the medium firm (6) version of the Signature Mattress delivered a better blend of support and comfort.

Our Performance Ratings

To evaluate how the Brooklyn Bedding Signature Hybrid Mattress performs, we conducted thorough tests in our sleep laboratory. Our diverse group of testers compiled both subjective and objective analyses to rate the mattress in eight key performance areas. 

Our team used a 5-point scale, with a rating of 1 indicating poor performance and 5 reflecting excellent performance. In some cases, performance in a particular category differed among the three models of the Signature Hybrid Mattress.

Pressure Relief

Rating: 4/5

All firmness options of the Brooklyn Bedding Signature Hybrid models demonstrated strong pressure relief in our testing. The mattress provides a cushioned surface that relieves pressure with light contouring while still resisting dramatic sinkage that could pull the spine out of alignment. 

Temperature Neutrality

Rating: 3/5 (Soft), 4/5 (Medium, Firm)

Our tests showed that the Signature Hybrid maintains a comfortable temperature, but the medium firm (6) and firm (8) versions stayed a little cooler. This is likely because they hug the body less, which enables better airflow. In all the models, however, the pocketed coil support core facilitates ventilation that limits heat buildup. 

Motion Isolation

Rating: 4/5 (Soft, Medium), 3/5 (Firm)

The Brooklyn Bedding Signature Hybrid Mattress is highly effective at isolating motion in the medium soft (4) and medium firm (6) models. Our testing found that these models were able to prevent vibrations from spreading across the mattress when one person moved around on the other side. However, the firm (8) model, which has more bounce and less contouring, was somewhat below average in isolating motion. The ability to prevent motion transfer is generally most important to couples or people who share their bed with a pet.

Edge Support

Rating: 3/5 (Soft/Medium), 4/5 (Firm)

The reinforced coils in the Brooklyn Bedding Signature Hybrid’s support core provide side-to-side edge support for all models. On the softer models, the foam sinks in a bit more when you sit or sleep near the bed’s perimeter. The firm (8) model scored well above average and offered a stable base of perimeter support for the testers in our lab.

Durability

Rating: 3/5

The Brooklyn Bedding Signature Hybrid is constructed with high-quality foam layers and steel coils that make for considerable durability. While the exact lifespan of this mattress can vary based on how it is used and maintained, we expect the Signature Hybrid to last for a similar amount of time as most hybrid mattresses. 

Ease of Movement

Rating: 3/5 (Soft), 4/5 (Medium, Firm)

Being able to move freely on a mattress can be helpful for those who shift sleep positions during the night, as well as those with mobility issues. With its notable bounce and responsive polyfoam layers, the firm (8) model of the Brooklyn Bedding Signature Hybrid is extremely easy to move on. The medium firm (6) and medium soft (4) models have softer top layers that add contouring and hug, which can lightly impede movement on the bed. 

Sex

Rating: 3/5 (Soft), 4/5 (Medium/Firm)

The Brooklyn Bedding Signature Hybrid is a solid option for people who prioritize a mattress that is good for sex. The thick layer of reinforced and pocketed coils generates a bouncy surface that is conducive to sexual activity, and the thin polyfoam base can dampen noise from the coils. The softer top layers add comfort as well, although the medium soft (4) model may slightly hinder movement because of its plusher surface.

Off-Gassing

Rating: 3/5

Off-gassing refers to the emission of volatile organic compounds, or VOCs, when a mattress is first unwrapped. VOCs are generally considered harmless, but the smell may be unpleasant. We found that the Brooklyn Bedding Signature Hybrid produces very little off-gassing regardless of the model. However, those who are sensitive to odors may want to set up the mattress in a well-ventilated area to help the off-gassing smell dissipate more quickly. 

What Is the Brooklyn Bedding Signature Mattress Made Of?

The Brooklyn Bedding Signature Hybrid Mattress’ design includes layers of cotton, polyfoam, and coils. The top layer is a breathable cover made of quilted cotton that is either 1 inch or 1.5 inches thick, depending on the model. 

The second layer is made of responsive and supportive polyfoam that can cushion pressure points while retaining plenty of bounce. Below that, a layer of transitional polyfoam prevents excess sagging or sinking into the mattress. 

The support core is made of an 8-inch layer of pocketed coils that sits on top of a .25-inch polyfoam base. The coils provide springiness and edge support to the mattress, and the foam base adds stability and reduces sound from the coils. 

The optional pillow-top adds about 2 inches of extra padding and includes fibers that are designed to prevent heat buildup.

Brooklyn Bedding Signature Mattress Construction Layers

Cover Material1” quilted cotton (Soft and Medium)
1.5” quilted cotton (Firm)
Comfort Layers1.5” polyfoam and 1” transition polyfoam (Soft and Medium)
1” polyfoam and 2” transition polyfoam (Firm)
Support Core8” pocketed coils and .25” polyfoam base

How Much Does the Brooklyn Bedding Signature Mattress Cost?

The Brooklyn Bedding Signature Mattress provides excellent value because of its high-performance construction and competitive price-point. All three firmness models have the same price, which includes free shipping. Pricing depends on the mattress size and whether you choose to add the optional pillow-top. 

In addition to the standard mattress sizes, Brooklyn Bedding offers the Signature Mattress in various hard-to-find sizes that can be especially appealing for people who need an RV mattress.

SizesPriceDimensionsHeightWeight
Twin$66538” x 74” 11.75”55 lbs. 
Twin XL$83238” x 80”11.75”70 lbs.
Full$99953” x 75” 11.75”90 lbs.
Queen$1,33260” x 80” 11.75”105 lbs.
King$1,59976” x 80” 11.75”120 lbs.
California King$1,59972” x 84” 11.75”120 lbs.

Which Brooklyn Bedding Mattress Is Right for You?

Brooklyn Bedding has a wide selection of mattresses with distinct constructions and features. All mattress purchases from Brooklyn Bedding are backed by a 120-night sleep trial. 

The Brooklyn Bedding Signature Hybrid has wide appeal, thanks to its hybrid design and multiple firmness options. It also strikes a solid balance between performance and price that can make it a real value for shoppers on a budget.

That said, other Brooklyn Bedding mattresses provide compelling alternatives. For example, the EcoSleep Luxe features natural and sustainable materials, the Aurora Luxe Hybrid includes multiple cooling technologies, and the Spartan Mattress uses far-infrared technology intended to boost muscle recovery, which can be especially useful for athletes.

Brooklyn Bedding Mattresses at a Glance

ModelFirmnessMattress TypeHeightBase Price (Queen)
Signature HybridMedium Soft (4), Medium Firm (6), Firm (8)Hybrid11.5”$1,332
Aurora LuxeMedium Soft (4), Medium Firm (6), Firm (7)Hybrid13.25”$1,865
EcoSleep Luxe Medium Soft (4), Firm (7)Hybrid11”$1,874
SpartanMedium Soft (4), Medium Firm (6), Firm (7)Hybrid13”$1,999
Sedona EliteMedium (5)Hybrid14”$2,399

Discounts and Coupons

Brooklyn Bedding regularly offers sales and seasonal promotions on their website, particularly around holidays. They also provide special discounts for military members, first responders, educators, medical providers, and students. 

Where Can You Buy the Brooklyn Bedding Signature Mattress?

Shoppers can get the Brooklyn Bedding Signature Hybrid Mattress online directly from the company, which makes each mattress in its factory in Arizona. Brooklyn Bedding also has showrooms in some states that offer the ability to see and test out their mattresses before making a purchase. 

The Signature Hybrid is also available from third-party retailers like Amazon. However, purchases from these vendors may not include the promotional pricing, sleep trial, and free shipping provided when buying directly from the Brooklyn Bedding website.

Buying Information and Customer Policies
AvailabilityThe Signature Mattress is available for purchase in the U.S. and Canada. Purchases can be made online directly from the manufacturer or at the Brooklyn Bedding showrooms that are listed on the company website. Mattresses are also available from select third-party retailers like Amazon.
ShippingShipping is free within the contiguous U.S. Shipping to Alaska, Hawaii, or Canada will incur additional fees. The mattress is usually delivered within 8 to 15 business days. It’s shipped compressed inside a large box that is delivered to your doorstep. To set up the mattress, bring the box to the room where you want it, remove the packaging, and allow it to decompress and regain its full size.
Additional ServicesWhite Glove delivery is not offered for this mattress. Old mattress removal and recycling is only offered to California residents.
Sleep TrialBrooklyn Bedding offers a 120-night sleep trial with a requirement that sleepers try the mattress for a minimum of 30 nights before initiating a return. All returns are subject to a $99 pickup fee that is deducted from the refunded amount. Returned mattresses are donated to a local charity or recycled.
WarrantyMattress purchases include a 10-year limited warranty that protects purchases against defects, sagging, and deterioration in the foam and other materials.

Brooklyn Bedding Signature Mattress FAQ

Should you get the cooling pillow-top for the Brooklyn Bedding Signature?

Hot sleepers who want a mattress with extra temperature regulation features should consider the pillow-top option, which includes GlacioTex material designed to resist heat buildup during the night. That said, even without the pillow-top, the Brooklyn Bedding Signature Hybrid performed well in our tests of temperature regulation, especially the medium firm (6) and firm (8) models.

Is the Brooklyn Bedding Signature good for combination sleepers?

The medium firm (6) model of the Brooklyn Bedding Signature Hybrid Mattress is a good option for most combination sleepers. With its mix of comfort and support, the medium firm version can accommodate multiple sleeping positions. It can also reduce motion isolation, so sleepers are less likely to bother their bed partner when changing positions.

The medium soft (4) and firm (7) options are less likely to be a good fit for combination sleepers since their constructions don’t suit as wide a variety of sleeping positions.

Where is the Brooklyn Bedding Signature Mattress made?

The Brooklyn Bedding Signature Hybrid Mattress is made in Brooklyn Bedding’s mattress factory in Phoenix, Arizona.

Does the Brooklyn Bedding Signature need a box spring?

You should use some type of support for the Brooklyn Bedding Signature Hybrid Mattress, but it doesn’t have to be a box spring. Other options include a platform or slat foundation that is stable and has limited or no flexion.

About The Author

Afy Okoye

Staff Writer, Sleep Health


Afy is a writer and creative strategist in San Francisco with a master’s degree in international health policy from the London School of Economics. She has written for VeryWell Health, BlackDoctor.org, and Paste magazine and edited peer-reviewed journal manuscripts for Elsevier. Afy says her work with The Sleep Doctor is anything but “sleepy.” She enjoys the opportunity to learn new information and share knowledge that gives people the power to make better choices. Afy also likes to read non-fiction, do creative writing, and travel solo.

  • POSITION: Side Sleeper
  • TEMPERATURE: Hot Sleeper
  • CHRONOTYPE: Bear

Ask the Sleep Doctor

Have questions about sleep? Submit them here! We use your questions to help us decide topics for articles, videos, and newsletters. We try to answer as many questions as possible. You can also send us an emailPlease note, we cannot provide specific medical advice, and always recommend you contact your doctor for any medical matters.