Best Crib Mattress of 2024:
Top Picks for Babies and Toddlers

Table of Contents

Babies spend many hours each day sleeping, so it’s important to choose a comfortable and supportive crib mattress. Purchasing your child’s bed takes careful consideration, as babies have different needs than adults.

While the federal government regulates crib dimensions as well as other safety aspects,  shoppers can choose the mattress type, thickness, and various performance features. With a range of models available today, parents can find a style that best suits their child’s needs.

We’ll highlight key factors like materials, construction methods, care guidelines, and company policies to help you narrow your search. We’ll also list our top mattress picks so you can pick the best crib mattress for your child.

The Best Crib Mattresses

Best Overall

Saatva Crib Mattress

SHOP NOW

Best Value

Newton Crib Mattress

SHOP NOW

Best Eco-Friendly

Brentwood Home EcoAir Waterproof Crib Mattress

SHOP NOW

Best for Babies and Toddlers

Avocado Luxury Organic Crib Mattress

SHOP NOW

Sleep Doctor’s Picks

Best Overall Mattress

Saatva Crib Mattress

The Sleep Doctor’s Review

The reversible Saatva Crib Mattress features a firm (7) side for infants, and a slightly softer medium firm (6) surface for toddlers. Cushioning latex and sturdy hourglass coils form a stable sleep surface that should hold up well until your child transitions to their own bed.

Buy From Saatva

Pros

• Breathable and water-resistant cotton cover
• Reversible model with two firmness levels
• Sturdy innerspring support system

Cons

• Pricier than the average crib mattress
• Only available in one profile

Saatva specializes in luxury mattresses made from natural and organic materials, and its Crib Mattress is no exception. The dual-sided model accommodates both infants and toddlers, which helps justify the steeper price tag.

Why We Like It

The shared support core uses recycled steel coils to stabilize the entire mattress. Double coils line the perimeter to help keep children in the center of the mattress. The coiled core also aids in temperature control since there’s more space for air to circulate.

All layers add up to 8 inches, which is slightly taller than the typical crib mattress. The removable organic cotton cover safeguards the bed from accidents and spills, thanks to a water-resistant treatment.

With a water-resistant cover, innerspring support system, and two firmness levels, the Saatva Crib Mattress is a good option for those seeking a mattress that suits babies and toddlers. Quality and organic materials might also appeal to eco-conscious shoppers.

How Does It Feel?

Each surface has a feel geared toward a specific developmental stage. The infant side is firmer and registers as a 7 on the 10-point firmness scale. Beneath the cover is a layer of woven eucalyptus fibers that cushions small bodies without trapping too much heat. The fabric also buffers infants from the mattress’ solid core.

The toddler side has a medium firm (6) feel that offers a little more give than the firmer surface. Organic wool below the cover eases pressure points while drawing away excess heat, and a layer of natural latex gives this side more bounce without sacrificing support. Latex also helps to resist allergen growth.

Best Value Mattress

Newton Crib Mattress

The Sleep Doctor’s Review

The Newton Crib Mattress is composed entirely of machine-washable materials, making it a practical choice that’s easy to keep clean. You can choose from multiple profiles and colors, and have the option to add a waterproof layer to the design.

Buy From Newton

Pros

• Specialized Wovenaire material has breathable properties that help keep the mattress cool
• GREENGUARD Gold certification ensures low chemical emissions
• Entire mattress is washable

Cons

• Single-sided design may not be equally suitable to babies and toddlers
• Machine washing the core can be time-consuming

The Essential Crib Mattress from Newton Baby is a thoughtfully constructed crib mattress made of a unique, breathable material. The price-point is reasonable compared to some other models that meet the same level of safety standards.

Why We Like It

Unlike competing models, the Essential Crib Mattress can be washed. Simply remove the cover and wash with soap and cool water in the shower or with a hose. Shake the bed to expel excess water then dry in a room with good ventilation.

How Does It Feel?

The mattress is 4 inches thick and is composed of Wovenaire, a specialized polymer material with a light and breathable composition. The mattress is encased in a single-layer viscose cover, which is similarly designed with breathability in mind. This design helps keep the surface temperature at a comfortable level so that your baby won’t overheat at night. The bed has GREENGUARD Gold certification, which means it has passed strict tests for low chemical emissions.

Best Eco-Friendly Mattress

Brentwood Home EcoAir Waterproof Crib Mattress

The Sleep Doctor’s Review

The reversible Brentwood EcoAir features dedicated infant and toddler sides, both coated in waterproof material to safeguard the mattress from liquid damage. All of the EcoAir’s components are machine-washable for quick and easy cleaning.

Buy From Brentwood Home

Pros

• Two-stage model for both infants and toddlers
• 100% washable design
• Waterproof liner on the toddler side

Cons

• Only available in a single profile
• Fairly expensive for a crib mattress

Brentwood Home’s EcoAir Waterproof Crib Mattress is a great choice for those who prioritize sustainable sourcing. The dual-sided model uses eco-friendly materials like organic cotton and recycled polyester to accommodate infants and toddlers. The mattress is also 100% washable, making it easy to clean.

Why We Like It

The mattress measures 4.5 inches thick, making it compatible with most standard cribs. Testing shows that off-gassing odors should be very minimal. The mattress performs especially well when it comes to durability and temperature control.

Designed to be used by babies and toddlers, the EcoAir Waterproof Crib Mattress offers a washable design, waterproof liner, and good temperature regulation. Shoppers seeking a mattress that’s easy to clean and made of durable materials should find the mattress meets their needs.

How Does It Feel?

The outer layer consists of REPREVE, a sustainable material made from recycled plastic bottles. Non-toxic silica on the fabric creates a natural fire barrier. The cover’s interior is made from breathable cotton that wicks away moisture. The toddler side has an additional polyester-blend lining that is water-repellent.

Below each cover is a 2.25-inch layer of polyethylene terephthalate (PETE), a porous material designed to resist heat buildup. The infant side uses a sturdy layer of PETE for a firm (7) feel. A softer layer of PETE on the opposite side creates a medium (5) feel better suited to toddlers. Both core layers and the removable cover are machine-washable.

Best Mattress for Babies and Toddlers

Avocado Luxury Organic Crib Mattress

The Sleep Doctor’s Review

The Avocado Luxury Organic Crib Mattress features a firm (7) side for babies and a medium firm (6) side for toddlers. Both are cushioned with organic latex and stabilized by strong pocketed coils, resulting in excellent overall support for your child during both crib stages.

Buy From Avocado

Pros

• Handcrafted dual-stage hybrid
• Made with naturally breathable materials
• Reinforced perimeter for strong edge support

Cons

• Much more expensive than the average crib mattress
• Lack of waterproofing materials can lead to mattress damage

Avocado has a reputation for its organic materials, sustainable sourcing, and quality craftsmanship. The brand’s Luxury Organic Crib Mattress uses the same standards to comfortably sleep infants and toddlers. The flippable hybrid has two distinct firmness options: a firm (7) surface tailored for infants and a reverse medium firm (6) side that supports toddlers. The mattress is 6 inches tall and is compatible with most standard cribs.

Why We Like It

The entire mattress is encased in organic wool, which functions as a natural fire barrier. Certifications like GOTS, OEKO-TEX, GOLS, and GREENGUARD Gold show that the materials adhere to strict safety standards.

With a hand-crafted design, multiple sustainability certifications, and natural materials, the Avocado Luxury Organic Crib Mattress is a good option for shoppers who value eco-friendly components. A reinforced perimeter makes the bed a good option for toddlers as well as babies, ensuring the mattress can be used for several years.

How Does It Feel?

Both sides are covered in organic cotton with a quilted pattern. On the infant side, a comfort layer made from coconut fibers cushions infants while wicking away excess heat. A layer of organic Dunlop latex below encourages good sleep posture for growing bodies. The toddler side also uses Dunlop latex, and the surface has slightly more bounce to accommodate movement.

The shared support core uses pocketed steel coils to reinforce the comfort layers. The coiled core absorbs noise and motion well since each spring is wrapped in cotton. A coconut fiber base pad keeps the mattress firmly in place. Additionally, hand-tufts are used instead of toxic glues to reinforce the internal components.

Why You Should Trust Us

Our testing team has decades of experience in the sleep industry. We run each product through the same set of rigorous tests. When it comes to crib mattresses, we pay special attention to safety, materials, firmness level, and durability.

Every family has different needs and budget considerations, so we test a variety of models that reflect a wide range of price-points so that you can find a crib mattress that best suits your child’s needs.

More Mattress Types

Best Custom Mattress Best Mattress for Airbnb Best Mattress for Bunk Beds Best Mattress on Amazon Best Mattress in Canada Best Online Mattress Best Orthopedic Mattress Best RV Mattress Best Mattress in a Box Best Truck Mattress Best Walmart Mattress

Mattresses by Construction

Best Memory Foam Mattress Best Hybrid Mattress Best Latex Mattress Best Organic Mattress Best Pillow Top Mattress Best Innerspring Mattress Best Flippable Mattress Best Smart Mattress Best Airbed Mattress

With so many factors to consider when shopping for a child’s bed, it can be difficult to know where to begin your search. We’ll discuss different mattress types, cleaning and care guidelines, and important safety considerations so you can optimize your child’s sleep space. 

Crib Mattress Types

Most crib mattresses are either foam or innerspring models, but there are additional options that utilize various natural and synthetic materials.

Each style has its pros and cons, but every crib mattress should meet the same health and safety requirements. 

Cleaning and Caring for Your Crib Mattress

It’s important to keep your child’s sleep environment sanitary. Care guidelines vary based on the materials and manufacturer, but a few safe cleaning tips can be used on most beds. 

Safety and Mattress Materials Certifications

It can be reassuring to know that your child’s bed meets strict health and safety standards. Various third-party certificates indicate the absence of harmful chemicals and contaminants. Other labels, such as CertiPUR-US and Greenguard Gold, indicate that a mattress was produced in an eco-friendly and socially responsible manner. 

Crib mattresses come in a variety of styles, but manufacturers must meet the size and safety standards established by the Consumer Product Safety Commission (CPSC). A full-size crib mattress should be at least 27.25 inches by 51.25 inches and not exceed 6 inches tall. Alternative styles like foldable mattresses can fall outside this range.

We’ll discuss the pros and cons of each mattress type so you can determine the best fit for your child’s needs. 

Innerspring Mattresses

This traditional mattress features a steel coil core and minimal comfort system. Innersprings are usually very supportive, and their responsiveness makes movement easier. They also tend to regulate temperature well since the space between coils promotes airflow. However, innersprings also weigh more than foam mattresses.

Foam Mattresses

These are some of the most lightweight mattresses since they are made entirely from foam. Most crib mattress models use polyfoam to balance comfort with support.

Foam is exceptionally good at absorbing motion and noise, which is helpful for children who easily awaken. Foam mattresses have some of the lowest price-points. However, shoppers  should avoid cheaper models, as they might use lower quality foams treated with chemicals and may form impressions quicker. Off-gassing can also be significant with certain foam models. 

Coconut Husk and Other Materials

Some companies use various natural and alternative materials not commonly seen in adult mattresses. These substitutes have their strengths and weaknesses, so it’s helpful to consider your child’s needs before committing to a model.

For example, coconut husk is a breathable, eco-friendly material that manufacturers often incorporate in crib mattresses. The fibers naturally repel moisture, which helps the mattress resist mold and bacterial growth. Coconut husks are elastic and durable, so they are often used in comfort and support layers.

Some crib mattresses combine innovative materials with the latest sleep technology. Keep in mind that manufacturers don’t always disclose the exact materials used in proprietary blends. 

Double-Sided Crib Mattresses

A double-sided mattress is designed to accompany your child as they grow. One side is usually firmer to support infants. As your child gets older, you can flip the mattress to reveal a slightly softer surface.

Many adults would find a crib mattress uncomfortably firm, but a solid surface is needed to prevent a child’s head and face from becoming enclosed within the mattress. A firm design also keeps a baby on their back, which is considered the safest sleeping position. Older babies have stronger muscles, so they can sleep on a mattress with a little more give. 

Every mattress has unique care requirements, so it’s best to follow the manufacturer’s guidelines. With that said, certain cleaning methods can be applied to most models.

Vacuuming the mattress’ surface helps remove dirt, dust, and other debris. Baking soda or child-safe detergent can be used to spot treat stains.

Many mattresses have removable covers that can be washed in standard household machines. Using the manufacturer’s recommended wash cycle and drying settings helps prevent premature wear. For models that are fully washable, you can clean the mattress’ core in a shower or bathtub and then air dry. 

Mattress Protectors and Reusable Underpads

Protectors and underpads can safeguard a mattress from accidents and spills. A mattress protector is a thin layer of material placed on top of a mattress and is designed to prevent dirt and moisture buildup. Protectors are made from both natural and synthetic materials. They are often water-resistant and machine-washable.

An underpad is also placed on top of a bed to protect the mattress from moisture and spills. While some designs only cover a portion of the mattress and are geared towards bed-wetting accidents,  most underpads are waterproof and machine-washable.

Is it Better to Have a Waterproof Mattress Instead?

Crib mattresses come in both waterproof and non-waterproof models. Some designs are 100% washable, though this is less common.

We’ll go over each style’s advantages and drawbacks below.

Waterproof vs. Non-Waterproof Mattresses

Can I Reuse a Crib Mattress?

It might be tempting to accept your friend or relative’s hand-me-down bed, but most experts don’t recommend reusing a crib mattress. Reused crib mattresses may be associated with an increased risk in SIDS,, especially if the bed came from another household. The exact link is unknown, but bacterial contamination and damage are suspected causes. 

Taking certain safety precautions can help give you peace of mind while your child sleeps.

• Back Sleeping: Back sleeping is the healthiest position for a baby since they are less likely to choke or suffocate. Stomach and side sleeping are both associated with a higher risk of SIDS. Once a child turns 1, they can transition to sleeping on their stomach.
• Inspect Crib for Hazards: Before you put your child to sleep, check the crib for sharp objects like splinters, nails, and burrs on metal hardware. Make sure that any heavy or suspended effects such as curtains, picture frames, or other decorative items are at a safe distance from the crib.
• Keep Items Out of the Crib: Your child’s crib should be very bare in order to minimize choking and suffocation hazards. Blankets, pillows, and other bedding should be reserved for when your child is older and sleeps in a bed. Soft objects like stuffed animals and crib bumpers are best avoided since they are linked to a higher risk of SIDS. 

Certifications You Should Keep an Eye Out For

You don’t want to cut any corners when it comes to your child’s safety. Third-party certifications help protect children by verifying certain health and safety standards. Shoppers can find these certifications or trust marks on manufacturer’s websites, product pages, and labels.

Below are the most common certifications for crib mattresses.

CertiPUR-US

This certificate is specific to foam and shows that harmful chemicals like formaldehyde, phthalates, heavy metals, and toxic flame retardants weren’t used during manufacturing. The certification also indicates that a product emits low levels of volatile organic compounds (VOCs).

Standard 100 by OEKO-TEX

Used for both textiles and foams, this rigorous certification tests for the presence of 100 substances. A product with this label has been shown to not contain any of these harmful contaminants.

Global Organic Textile Standard (GOTS)

GOTS certification ensures that materials meet organic standards and were produced in a socially responsible way. Textiles with this label undergo careful inspection, from sourcing through each processing stage.

GREENGUARD Gold

Products with Greenguard Gold certification meet stringent standards for VOCs and other chemical emissions. Crib mattresses with this trust mark should have minimal off-gassing.

About The Author

Garen Glazier

Staff Writer, Product Testing Team

---

Garen is a health and lifestyle content creator. She realized the importance of sleep when her children made getting a good night’s rest more challenging. Garen is always learning something new about the wide world of sleep and sleep products. Married with two girls, ages 7 and 11, she is a book nerd and a lover of pop music, travel, and the Pacific Northwest.

• POSITION: Side Sleeper
• TEMPERATURE: Neutral Sleeper
• CHRONOTYPE: Wolf

Get Your Sleep Questions Answered Live on 4/30

Have questions about sleep? Get all your sleep-related questions answered in a Live Q&A on YouTube with renowned sleep expert Dr. Michael Breus at 5 p.m. PST/8 p.m. EST.